Recreation Groups Argue for New Law Before Ninth Circuit

Share on Facebook
December 14, 2010 7:00 AM
Associated Image

PASADENA, CA (December 14) — The extent to which nonfederal parties can participate in environmental litigation is now under review by an en banc panel of the U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals following a case argued on December 13, 2010. The appellants are motorized recreation interests who have been excluded from participation and are asking the Circuit to change the law. Arguing for them was Paul Turcke, the Boise, Idaho, attorney who has been lead counsel for the BlueRibbon Coalition Legal Program since its inception in 1996. Also arguing was Paul Gale, who represented the Motorcycle Industry Council (MIC) and Specialty Vehicle Institute of America (SVIA), who obtained "friend of the court" status in support of the recreation groups.

The case was originally brought in the U.S. District of Idaho by preservationist organizations who sued the Forest Service seeking greater restrictions on motorized vehicle access to the Minidoka Ranger District of the Sawtooth National Forest. The Magic Valley Trail Machine Association, the Idaho Recreation Council and BlueRibbon were denied intervention in the case. The district court ruled, in large part, that intervention was prevented by the "Federal Defendant Rule," unique to the Ninth Circuit, which maintains that since only "the federal defendant" must comply with statutes like the National Environmental Policy Act, only the federal defendant can be a party to a suit alleging noncompliance with such "environmental" laws.

The appeal was initially argued on March 9, 2010, to a three-judge Ninth Circuit panel by Turcke, opposed not by "the federal defendant" but by lawyers with the Western Environmental Law Center. Rather than issuing a decision, the panel asked for further briefing on the question of whether the Court should convene en banc to consider abandoning the Federal Defendant Rule. On September 30, 2010, the Court issued an order indicating that a majority of nonrecused active judges on the court voted to hear the appeal en banc.

An en banc proceeding is unusual and is ordered only when necessary to establish or maintain uniformity of prior court decisions or when the proceeding involves a question of great importance. Under Ninth Circuit rule, an en banc court consists of the Chief Judge of the circuit and ten additional judges drawn by lot from the active judges of the circuit.

After the Court announced it would rehear the case en banc, numerous parties in addition to MIC-SVIA submitted "friend of the court" briefs in support of the recreation groups' position. They include the Kootenai, Coquille, Kalispel, Shoshone-Bannock and other Indian tribes; Coos, Grant, Harney and Wallowa Counties, Oregon; the State of Alaska; Idaho Governor Otter and Office of Species Conservation; Western Urban Water Coalition; Southern Nevada Water Authority; American Petroleum Institute, Chamber of Commerce of the U.S.A. and National Manufacturers Association; American Forest Resource Council; Public Lands Council and the National Cattlemen's Beef Association; and Safari Club International.

A video recording of this argument is available for public viewing at http://www.ca9.uscourts.gov/media/view_subpage.php?pk_vid=0000006124. The status of this and other cases being considered en banc, including the names of individual panel members, can be viewed on the Court's website at http://www.ca9.uscourts.gov/enbanc/.

E&E News Article
LITIGATION: Court to weigh private interests' intervention in NEPA disputes
http://www.sharetrails.org/public_lands/?section=EandE_News_13

# # #

The BlueRibbon Coalition is a national recreation group that champions responsible recreation, and encourages individual environmental stewardship. With members in all 50 states, BRC is focused on building enthusiast involvement with organizational efforts through membership, outreach, education, and collaboration among recreationists. 1-800-BlueRib - www.sharetrails.org

December 18, 2014 10:58 AM
BRC’s Don Amador tours Oceano Dunes SVRA

OAKLEY, CA (December 18, 2014) -- A highly popular off-road state park located on the central coast of California was host last week for a government body that oversees the operation. On December 11 & 12, the California State Park's Off-Highway Motor Vehicle Recreation (OHMVR) Commission met in Grover Beach. Commissioners toured the Oceano Dunes State Vehicular Area (SVRA) and discussed many aspects of the CA OHV program statewide including various operational tenets of the SVRA. 

Read more...
November 5, 2014 5:27 PM
Del Albright, BRC Director of Operations, and his rig.

POCATELLO, ID (November 4, 2014) -- The BlueRibbon Coalition (BRC) is proud to announce the recent induction of one of its own, Del Albright, into the Off-Road Motorsports Hall of Fame (ORMHOF). Del has been a long time advocate of recreation access, and originally served as BRC's organizational facilitator, after which he served for many years as a BRC Ambassador to the recreation community. Most recently, he has been serving as BRC's Director of Operations.

Read more...
October 29, 2014 11:56 AM
Grant Gerber, with his horse, Gandhi.

ELKO, NV (October 29, 2014) -- Grant Gerber, a long-time advocate for public access to public lands (and a true cowboy of the open range), passed away recently. "He [is] remembered for dedicating his life to fighting for local rights against federal encroachment," read the story in the Elko Daily Free Press, the local newspaper for Grant's hometown. But to the BlueRibbon Coalition (BRC) and the OHV community, he was much more.

Read more...
[Press Room Archive]